Garden of Choices

Resources for Argument Analysis

Argument Analysis
When analysing argument, identify the persuasive techniques in a text in relation to the author ‘s contention.

Consider the language components below and examine how I use them in Garden of Choices to influence my audience. These are the devices you learn to identify, explore and use in argument analysis.

Contention
Usually, a writer’s main argument (the contention) is immediately stated. Especially in opinion pieces and speeches, which are commonly explored in this unit of study, the contention is either in the title or in the first paragraph. However, an unreliable narrator like me can draw out the real argument. I use positive phrases - ‘she winked’ ‘generous nudging’ ‘responding to his good deeds’ - to throw you off Apple’s true intention, and make you work to find my contention: Don’t fall for the devil’s sneaky temptations.

Refer to an opinion piece or speech. Examine the first paragraph. What does the writer want you to believe? This is the contention. Compare the texts. This title. This front cover. Do they hint at my contention? Now examine the title of your persuasive text. What is it hinting?

Arguments
I foreshadow several points to support my contention which is only crystal clear after the whole story has been told. The very last page reveals that Apple is unquestionably rotten. This is exposed using the allegorical theme of the Garden of Eden. In the same way the snake tempts Eve with the apple in Genesis, Apple herself tempts Orange in this story.

Once this is clear, the arguments are too:
1.The majority is not always right: Most of the Fruit in the Garden have taken a bite of Apple. Orange is a minority.
2.Nice gestures sometimes hide bad intentions: Apple seemingly supports Orange with his sick mum but it’s just a ploy in an attempt to corrupt him.
3.The antagonist can be our mirror: Foreshadowed on page 9, where Orange sees his own reflection in Apple’s skin, his faults mirror her flaws. He identifies that Apple is showy, bossy and lacks discipline on page 19. Then he succumbs to the same faults on page 21-22: boasting, impelling and gluttonous eating.

Find these arguments in this book. Consider the words I use to create them. Now refer to your opinion piece. Annotate its key vocabulary and language devices to find the arguments.

Rhetorical Appeals: Modes of Persuasion:
Ethos (building credibility)
Initial trust is built through the characterisation of Apple. She appeals to the audience with her mischievousness, her confidence and her popularity. Even the book cover suggests that Apple is friendly. Seemingly wanting to share herself with Orange and never giving up on him, Apple is trusted to be cheeky with good intentions.

Locate the words/phrases/sentences that make Apple seem credible and nice. Now find language that builds credibility in your opinion piece.

When the unreliable narrator is exposed, clues are remembered, and my credibility is secured. I foreshadow the apple of temptation in the front cover and then confirm it on the last page with the Garden of Eden. I foreshadow Apple's plan to allure Orange into tasting her in the beginning of the story and confirm it near the end with the banquet made of apples. These work to further persuade my audience, because even though I trick you in believing that 'she’s no rotten Apple', I never lie.

Pathos (emotional persuasion)
By embedding the 9 Fruits of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control) into the story, I influence the audience to refer to biblical foundations. It helps readers feel the effects of these Fruits from the perspective of Orange and his mum.

Find the 9 Fruit of the Spirit in this text and respond to how they position you, the audience. What do they make you feel, think or want to do? How do they build the characters? How do they move the story? Now find examples of pathos in your persuasive piece.

Strong verbs like ‘generous’ and ‘suffer’ are used as a ploy, warning audience to beware of sensationalism.

Find examples of strong language in your persuasive text. How do they persuade you? Are they genuine or a ploy? Why do you think so?

Logos (reasoning)
Apple uses reasoning to persuade Orange to let her help him, ‘My talents and my many fruit friends can be of service’. Mum uses reasoning to put thoughts into perspective, ‘It’s not our job to judge them. Our job is to review situations before making OUR choices.’

When the readers compare these approaches, it becomes clear that Apple’s reasoning is centred on vanity while mum’s is centred on good values. These parallels show logical contrasts in the characters' and their intentions, hinting at Apple's true nature.

Reasoning is also implied when mum steps out of bed (in the last page). I make you worry for a moment when Apple's 'smile broadens'. Initially, it may seem that mum has been corrupted. However, when you apply reasoning, recalling her level head and strong faith throughout the story, you realise that this is unlikely. It is more reasonable to conclude that she has simply recovered, turning your worries to her impressionable son. It's reasonable to fear that by nursing his mum back to health, Apple has likely achieved her goal of impressing Orange.


Consider how reasoning is used in your persuasive piece. Are there parallels that demonstrate contrasting reasoning? Does the writer build a logical profile of their contention? How else do they reason with you?

Antanaclasis
I use this figure of rhetoric in the phrase, ‘…ensuring you eat well to get well’ (p.22). Using the same word twice in one sentence to form two meanings is antanaclasis. Repeating the homonym ‘well’ to mean first ‘good’ and then ‘healthy’ brings attention to Orange’s moment of hypocrisy. As an unreliable narrator, I give the protagonist the same flaw as the antagonist to make you question his integrity.


Appeals
Apple uses several appeals to mislead Orange. Eventually, this works to reveal her own true nature and persuade the audience to look beyond her friendly exterior.

  • Appeal to patriotism: using Orange’s love for his culture to manipulate him: ‘You give the Citrus culture a bad name’.

  • Appeal to humour: using funny and clever play with words to give her a likeable demeanour: ‘Bright in colour but not in intellect’.

  • Appeal to guilt: using Orange’s love for his mum to convince him to let her in: ‘Don’t you want your mum to receive good care? Trying to do it all alone will only extend her suffering’.

  • Appeal to fear: using dramatic irony to show the audience what Orange cannot yet see (that he's being manipulated): ‘In this Garden of Choices, I will always be tempting’.


Use one of these appeals to write an additional argument for your persuasive piece.

Literary devices:
Onomatopoeia is used as a false truth (page 17). Bringing attention to Apple’s ‘generous’ support, the long list of these words highlight Apple’s efforts in the kitchen, but also, her effortful process of deception.

Read page 17 again. How do I use onomatopoeia to persuade you to be on team Apple?

Grammatical Moods:
Like the ho-hums of moody people, language too has its moods. There are four key moods in English grammar: imperative, interrogative, indicative and subjunctive. This is how they affect the mood of this story:
1.Imperative (bossy and commanding) e.g. ‘…let yourself taste me’.
2.Interrogative (suspicious and questioning) e.g. ‘You call yourself juicy?’
3.Indicative (informative and straightforward) e.g.’…people have many dimensions.’
4.Subjunctive (wishful and conditional) e.g. ‘If you had any sense at all, you’d let yourself taste me’.

Find one example of each of these moods in your persuasive piece.

Grammaticality:
In this picture book, partitives (small parts of a whole) are used to show the many small ways in which wrongs can be disguised and seem 'inconsequential'. The list of these words (page 23) infer warning to the audience: beware of small wrongs that hide and grow.

Read page 23 again. How do these partitives persuade you to,'review situations before making...choices?

Fallacies
Apple uses these false truths to corrupt Orange:

  • Bandwagon: Points out that most Fruit agree with her in an attempt to use peer pressure to have Orange join them: ‘Everyone else said yes’.

  • Ad Hominem: Attacks Orange personally to shame him into changing his mind: ‘You call yourself juicy? You’re supposed to be bright!’


Write an additional paragraph for your persuasive text using one of these fallacies.

Call to Action
My indeterminate ending (intentionally unresolved) leaves Orange's fate unclear. I deliberately keep him torn between his mum's good advice and his fascination with Apple to highlight the devil's sneaky temptations. Through Orange’s moral dilemma, I call you to consider intention before being influenced by others. I call you to pay attention to small thoughts and small decisions that contribute to big mistakes. And most of all, I call you to listen to that ‘joyful voice in (your) heart’; It’s God talking.

Read the last paragraph of your persuasive text and identify what the creator wants you, the audience, to do, think or feel - what's the call to action?

Using the persuasive devices discussed above, write your own persuasive story using the Garden of Choices as a mentor text. Then write a persuasive speech on this topic: Listen to that joyful voice in your heart; It's God talking.
​